Herbert H Carnegie Public School vs St Mary Immaculate Catholic Elementary School
A head-to-head comparison of two elementary schools in Ontario, Canada, 2.2 km apart, using official Canadian 2025 data. The better value in each row is highlighted.
Herbert H Carnegie Public School
Maple · Public elementary · Grades JK-8
595 students
St Mary Immaculate Catholic Elementary School
Richmond Hill · Catholic elementary · Grades JK-8
320 students
| Measure | Herbert H Carnegie Public School Maple, Ontario | St Mary Immaculate Catholic Elementary School Richmond Hill, Ontario |
|---|---|---|
| Success Index (Canada) | 73 Top 25% | 80 Top 10% |
| Province rank | #637 of 3,871 | #337 of 3,871 |
| National rank | #637 of 3,871 | #337 of 3,871 |
| Sector | Public | Catholic |
| Type | Elementary | Elementary |
| Year range | Grades JK-8 | Grades JK-8 |
| Students | 595 | 320 |
| Enrolment | 595 | 320 |
| EQAO Grade 3 | 82.7% | 82.7% |
| EQAO Grade 6 | 84% | 90.7% |
| EQAO Grade 9 maths | – | – |
| OSSLT pass rate | – | – |
| Low-income households | 6% | 10% |
| Parents without a credential | 3% | 0% |
| First language not English | 43% | 30% |
| Special education | 15% | 10% |
| Identified as gifted | 1% | 0% |
| FSA literacy score | – | – |
| FSA numeracy score | – | – |
| FSA Grade 4 literacy score | – | – |
| FSA Grade 4 numeracy score | – | – |
| FSA Grade 7 literacy score | – | – |
| FSA Grade 7 numeracy score | – | – |
| city or town | Maple | Richmond Hill |
| province | Ontario | Ontario |
| Website | herberthcarnegie.ps.yrdsb.ca/ | smi.ycdsb.ca |
The verdict
- •St Mary Immaculate Catholic Elementary School scores higher on the Success Index (Canada) (79.7 vs 73.2).
- •St Mary Immaculate Catholic Elementary School does better on eqao grade 6 (reading, writing, maths) (90.7% vs 84%).
- •Herbert H Carnegie Public School is the larger school with 595 students compared with 320.
- •Herbert H Carnegie Public School is a public school while St Mary Immaculate Catholic Elementary School is a catholic school, so fees and admission rules differ.
The Success Index (Canada) summarises published results and context from official data. It does not measure teaching quality or fit. Methodology.
Free academic assessment
Torn between two schools? Start with your child.
Whichever you choose, a free Success Tutoring assessment shows exactly where your child is in English and Maths and how to get ahead before the next school year.
- Personalised learning plan mapped to the Australian Curriculum
- English & Maths from Kindergarten to Year 12
- Flexible memberships, no lock-in contracts
- Centres across NSW, VIC, QLD, WA, SA and ACT
Frequently asked questions
Is Herbert H Carnegie Public School better than St Mary Immaculate Catholic Elementary School?
On the Success Index (Canada), St Mary Immaculate Catholic Elementary School ranks higher (79.7 vs 73.2 out of 100). The index is built from published results and context data, not from teaching quality or fit, so visit both schools before deciding.
How far apart are Herbert H Carnegie Public School and St Mary Immaculate Catholic Elementary School?
About 2.2 km in a straight line, between Maple and Richmond Hill in Ontario.
Which has the better Enrolment?
Herbert H Carnegie Public School: 595. St Mary Immaculate Catholic Elementary School: 320. Students enrolled in the latest published year.
How do Herbert H Carnegie Public School and St Mary Immaculate Catholic Elementary School rank in Ontario?
Herbert H Carnegie Public School is 637th of 3,871 and St Mary Immaculate Catholic Elementary School is 337th of 3,871 among elementary schools in Ontario on the 2025 Success Index (Canada).