Skip to content
S

Best elementary schools in Indianapolis (2025)

Schools classified as elementary by NCES. Ranked by the Success Index (US) from official American data; 100 schools in Indianapolis, Indiana. Rank positions shown on each profile are within United States and Indiana.

  1. 1
    89
    Joseph J. Bingham School 84 Center for InquiryIndianapolis · Public Elementary77% Math proficiency · 360 students
  2. 2
    84
    Merle Sidener Academy 59 - a High Ability SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary78% Math proficiency · 228 students
  3. 3
    83
    Herron Preparatory AcademyIndianapolis · Charter Elementary36.4% Free/reduced-price lunch · 428 students
  4. 4
    72
    South Creek ElementaryIndianapolis · Public Elementary79% Math proficiency · 476 students
  5. 5
    70
    Benjamin Harrison School 2 Center for InquiryIndianapolis · Public Elementary50% Math proficiency · 303 students
  6. 6
    70
    The Nature School of Central IndianaIndianapolis · Charter Elementary5.1% Free/reduced-price lunch · 175 students
  7. 7
    68
    Rosa Parks Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary75% Math proficiency · 658 students
  8. 8
    68
    Bunker Hill Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary77% Math proficiency · 487 students
  9. 9
    68
    Acton Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary75% Math proficiency · 275 students
  10. 10
    67
    Thompson Crossing Elementary SchIndianapolis · Public Elementary74% Math proficiency · 568 students
  11. 11
    67
    Allisonville Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary64% Math proficiency · 724 students
  12. 12
    66
    Amy Beverland ElementaryIndianapolis · Public Elementary67% Math proficiency · 800 students
  13. 13
    66
    Forest Glen Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary70% Math proficiency · 971 students
  14. 14
    65
    Paramount Cottage HomeIndianapolis · Charter Elementary74.5% Math proficiency · 381 students
  15. 15
    64
    Mary Adams Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary66% Math proficiency · 451 students
  16. 16
    61
    Arlington Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary63% Math proficiency · 454 students
  17. 17
    61
    Douglas MacArthur Elementary SchIndianapolis · Public Elementary65% Math proficiency · 579 students
  18. 18
    61
    George Washington Carver School 87 - a Montessori SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary52% Math proficiency · 246 students
  19. 19
    60
    Grassy Creek Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary67% Math proficiency · 516 students
  20. 20
    60
    Southport Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary59% Math proficiency · 450 students
  21. 21
    60
    Glenns Valley Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary63% Math proficiency · 533 students
  22. 22
    58
    Paramount BrooksideIndianapolis · Charter Elementary69% Math proficiency · 843 students
  23. 23
    58
    Fishback Creek Public AcademyIndianapolis · Public Elementary52% Math proficiency · 510 students
  24. 24
    57
    New Bethel Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary47.4% Free/reduced-price lunch · 439 students
  25. 25
    55
    Crooked Creek Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary58% Math proficiency · 460 students
  26. 26
    54
    PLA@Promise PrepIndianapolis · Charter Elementary65.3% Free/reduced-price lunch · 144 students
  27. 27
    54
    Mary Bryan Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary59% Math proficiency · 644 students
  28. 28
    53
    Decatur High Ability AcademyIndianapolis · Public Elementary48.5% Free/reduced-price lunch · 103 students
  29. 29
    53
    Mary Nicholson School 70 Center for InquiryIndianapolis · Public Elementary44% Math proficiency · 351 students
  30. 30
    53
    PLA at George H Fisher School 93Indianapolis · Charter Elementary74.3% Free/reduced-price lunch · 417 students
  31. 31
    52
    Eagle Creek Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary51% Math proficiency · 533 students
  32. 32
    52
    Clearwater Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary39.6% Free/reduced-price lunch · 750 students
  33. 33
    52
    William Bell School 60 - a Butler Lab Reggio Emilia SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary38% Math proficiency · 381 students
  34. 34
    50
    Lynwood ElementaryIndianapolis · Public Elementary65.5% Free/reduced-price lunch · 583 students
  35. 35
    50
    Phalen Leadership Academy - IN IncIndianapolis · Charter Elementary57% Math proficiency · 247 students
  36. 36
    50
    William Henry Burkhart ElementaryIndianapolis · Public Elementary57% Math proficiency · 449 students
  37. 37
    49
    Early Learning CenterIndianapolis · Public Elementary38% Free/reduced-price lunch · 1,313 students
  38. 38
    49
    Mary Evelyn Castle Elementary SchIndianapolis · Public Elementary52% Math proficiency · 778 students
  39. 39
    49
    The PATH SchoolIndianapolis · Charter Elementary71.8% Free/reduced-price lunch · 705 students
  40. 40
    49
    Charity Dye School 27 Center for InquiryIndianapolis · Public Elementary35% Math proficiency · 348 students
  41. 41
    48
    Louis B Russell Jr School 48Indianapolis · Charter Elementary79.2% Free/reduced-price lunch · 274 students
  42. 42
    47
    Homecroft Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary58% Math proficiency · 493 students
  43. 43
    46
    Allegiant Preparatory AcademyIndianapolis · Charter Elementary68.7% Free/reduced-price lunch · 166 students
  44. 44
    46
    Willow Lake Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary53% Free/reduced-price lunch · 739 students
  45. 45
    46
    Jeremiah Gray Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary53% Math proficiency · 591 students
  46. 46
    46
    Crestview Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary46% Math proficiency · 591 students
  47. 47
    46
    McClelland Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary46% Math proficiency · 809 students
  48. 48
    46
    Tindley Genesis AcademyIndianapolis · Charter Elementary57% Math proficiency · 368 students
  49. 49
    46
    Rousseau McClellan School 91 - a Montessori SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary39% Math proficiency · 506 students
  50. 50
    45
    Douglas MacArthur KindergartenIndianapolis · Public Elementary64.5% Free/reduced-price lunch · 273 students
  51. 51
    45
    Abraham Lincoln Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary53% Math proficiency · 633 students
  52. 52
    45
    Washington Irving Neighborhood School 14Indianapolis · Public Elementary77.4% Free/reduced-price lunch · 230 students
  53. 53
    44
    Chapelwood Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary53% Math proficiency · 776 students
  54. 54
    44
    Robey Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary47% Math proficiency · 847 students
  55. 55
    44
    Spring Mill Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary43% Math proficiency · 529 students
  56. 56
    43
    Phalen at Francis Scott Key 103Indianapolis · Charter Elementary74% Free/reduced-price lunch · 689 students
  57. 57
    43
    Guion Creek Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary43% Math proficiency · 550 students
  58. 58
    42
    Emma Donnan Elementary and MiddleIndianapolis · Charter Elementary81.4% Free/reduced-price lunch · 451 students
  59. 59
    41
    Irvington Community Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Charter Elementary67.9% Free/reduced-price lunch · 402 students
  60. 60
    41
    Bethel Park Elementary | pilotED SchoolsIndianapolis · Charter Elementary68% Free/reduced-price lunch · 225 students
  61. 61
    40
    IN Math & Science AcademyIndianapolis · Charter Elementary43% Math proficiency · 554 students
  62. 62
    39
    Rosa Parks KindergartenIndianapolis · Public Elementary61.7% Free/reduced-price lunch · 295 students
  63. 63
    39
    Oaklandon Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary41% Math proficiency · 507 students
  64. 64
    39
    Hawthorne Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary42% Math proficiency · 404 students
  65. 65
    38
    Lowell Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary47% Math proficiency · 466 students
  66. 66
    38
    Theodore Potter School 74 - a Dual Language SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary27% Math proficiency · 208 students
  67. 67
    38
    Bridgeport Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary39% Math proficiency · 692 students
  68. 68
    37
    Fox Hill Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary39% Math proficiency · 603 students
  69. 69
    37
    Ernie Pyle School 90 - a Paideia SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary37% Math proficiency · 268 students
  70. 70
    37
    Stout Field Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary43% Math proficiency · 617 students
  71. 71
    36
    Invent Learning HubIndianapolis · Charter Elementary94.1% Free/reduced-price lunch · 221 students
  72. 72
    36
    Nora Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary38% Math proficiency · 544 students
  73. 73
    36
    Blue AcademyIndianapolis · Public Elementary39% Math proficiency · 687 students
  74. 74
    36
    Greenbriar Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary36% Math proficiency · 509 students
  75. 75
    36
    Winchester Village ElementaryIndianapolis · Public Elementary45% Math proficiency · 546 students
  76. 76
    35
    Paramount Online AcademyIndianapolis · Charter Elementary71.2% Free/reduced-price lunch · 163 students
  77. 77
    34
    Eastridge Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary37% Math proficiency · 424 students
  78. 78
    34
    Homecroft KindergartenIndianapolis · Public Elementary73.8% Free/reduced-price lunch · 359 students
  79. 79
    34
    Jeremiah Gray KindergartenIndianapolis · Public Elementary63.3% Free/reduced-price lunch · 417 students
  80. 80
    34
    Liberty Park Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary42% Math proficiency · 443 students
  81. 81
    34
    Eliza Baker School 55 - a Butler Lab Reggio Emilia SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary22% Math proficiency · 301 students
  82. 82
    34
    Brookview Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary46% Math proficiency · 507 students
  83. 83
    33
    Christel House Academy SouthIndianapolis · Charter Elementary37% Math proficiency · 513 students
  84. 84
    33
    Westlake Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary32% Math proficiency · 736 students
  85. 85
    33
    Gold AcademyIndianapolis · Public Elementary33% Math proficiency · 529 students
  86. 86
    33
    New Augusta Public Academy - SouthIndianapolis · Public Elementary26% Math proficiency · 437 students
  87. 87
    32
    Meredith Nicholson School 96 - an Exploratory SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary23% Math proficiency · 391 students
  88. 88
    32
    Pleasant Run Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary42% Math proficiency · 561 students
  89. 89
    31
    College Park Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary31% Math proficiency · 518 students
  90. 90
    31
    George W. Julian School 57 Center for InquiryIndianapolis · Public Elementary22% Math proficiency · 165 students
  91. 91
    31
    Lakeside Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary38% Math proficiency · 527 students
  92. 92
    30
    Valley Mills Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary29% Math proficiency · 554 students
  93. 93
    30
    Eastbrook Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary27% Math proficiency · 575 students
  94. 94
    29
    Cold Spring SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary17% Math proficiency · 359 students
  95. 95
    29
    Sunny Heights Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary37% Math proficiency · 485 students
  96. 96
    29
    Snacks Crossing Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary31% Math proficiency · 793 students
  97. 97
    29
    Stephen Decatur Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary33% Math proficiency · 496 students
  98. 98
    28
    Jonathan Jennings School 109 - an Exploratory SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary17% Math proficiency · 275 students
  99. 99
    28
    Indian Creek Elementary SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary36% Math proficiency · 712 students
  100. 100
    28
    James A. Garfield School 31 - a STEM SchoolIndianapolis · Public Elementary22% Math proficiency · 173 students

Joseph J. Bingham School 84 Center for Inquiry in Indianapolis leads the 2025 list of elementary schools in Indianapolis with a Success Index (US) of 89.3. Of the 100 schools shown, 81 are public, 19 are charter.

For the full picture see the wider Indiana elementary schools rankings, every school on the Indianapolis page, or the comparison tool to put a shortlist side by side.

Free academic assessment

Is your child on grade level in reading and math?

Success Tutoring offers personalised English and math tutoring from Kindergarten to Grade 12. Start with a free online assessment and a clear plan for the year ahead.

  • Personalised learning plan mapped to the Australian Curriculum
  • English & Maths from Kindergarten to Year 12
  • Flexible memberships, no lock-in contracts
  • Centres across NSW, VIC, QLD, WA, SA and ACT

No cost, no obligation. By submitting you agree to be contacted by Success Tutoring about your enquiry. See our privacy policy.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best elementary school in Indianapolis?

Joseph J. Bingham School 84 Center for Inquiry in Indianapolis, Indiana ranks first among elementary schools in Indianapolis with a Success Index (US) of 89.3 out of 100 (Enrollment: 360).

How are elementary schools in Indianapolis ranked?

Each school's Success Index (US) combines 4 factors: math proficiency (30%), reading proficiency (30%), community advantage (fewer free/reduced-price lunch) (25%), students per teacher (15%). Each factor is a percentile against schools of the same type across United States. Schools with fewer than 60 students are excluded from rankings.

Are these 2025 rankings official?

No. They are computed by Success Tutoring from official American data (Urban Institute Education Data Portal (NCES CCD, EDFacts); NCES Common Core of Data). States set their own assessments and proficiency cut scores, so proficiency rates are most comparable within a state. Use the state rankings for like-for-like comparisons.