Best elementary schools in Fayetteville (2025)

Schools classified as elementary by NCES. Ranked by the Success Index (US) from official American data; 36 schools in Fayetteville, North Carolina. Rank positions shown on each profile are within United States and North Carolina.

1
44
Stoney Point ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary51% Math proficiency · 780 students
2
42
Long Hill ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary50% Math proficiency · 412 students
3
42
Vanstory Hills ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary45% Math proficiency · 514 students
4
40
J W Seabrook ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary52% Math proficiency · 271 students
5
39
E Melvin Honeycutt ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary46% Math proficiency · 782 students
6
38
New Century International ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary44% Math proficiency · 686 students
7
37
Howard L Hall ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary42% Math proficiency · 539 students
8
31
College Lakes ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary35% Math proficiency · 459 students
9
30
E E Miller ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary41% Math proficiency · 656 students
10
29
J W Coon ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary32% Math proficiency · 186 students
11
28
Brentwood ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary32% Math proficiency · 494 students
12
25
Ashley ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary27% Math proficiency · 180 students
13
25
Alderman Road ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary37% Math proficiency · 655 students
14
25
Elizabeth M Cashwell ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary34% Math proficiency · 576 students
15
24
Glendale Acres ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary98.8% Free/reduced-price lunch · 251 students
16
23
Cumberland Road ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary27% Math proficiency · 337 students
17
23
Lucile Souders ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary28% Math proficiency · 399 students
18
22
Cliffdale ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary24% Math proficiency · 613 students
19
22
Warrenwood ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary27% Math proficiency · 424 students
20
21
Ponderosa ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary32% Math proficiency · 417 students
21
21
Montclair ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary22% Math proficiency · 433 students
22
21
William H Owen ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary22% Math proficiency · 393 students
23
20
Sherwood Park ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary17% Math proficiency · 335 students
24
20
Benjamin J Martin ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary25% Math proficiency · 522 students
25
20
Cumberland Mills ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary31% Math proficiency · 573 students
26
19
Margaret Willis ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary22% Math proficiency · 296 students
27
19
Loyd E Auman ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary25% Math proficiency · 495 students
28
19
Bill Hefner ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary24% Math proficiency · 712 students
29
18
Mary McArthur ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary24% Math proficiency · 447 students
30
17
Lake Rim ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary22% Math proficiency · 656 students
31
17
Westarea ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary18% Math proficiency · 546 students
32
16
Walker-Spivey ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary22% Math proficiency · 345 students
33
16
Alma O Easom ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary99% Free/reduced-price lunch · 301 students
34
15
Morganton Road ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary23% Math proficiency · 491 students
35
14
Ferguson-Easley ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary17% Math proficiency · 392 students
36
13
Sunnyside ElementaryFayetteville · Public Elementary22% Math proficiency · 362 students

#	School	Sector	Success Index (US)	Key result	Students
1	Stoney Point Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades K–5	Public	44.4 Lower 50%	51% Math proficiency	780
2	Long Hill Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades 2–5	Public	42.3 Lower 50%	50% Math proficiency	412
3	Vanstory Hills Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades 2–5	Public	41.5 Lower 50%	45% Math proficiency	514
4	J W Seabrook Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	39.8 Lower 50%	52% Math proficiency	271
5	E Melvin Honeycutt Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades K–5	Public	39.4 Lower 50%	46% Math proficiency	782
6	New Century International Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	37.7 Lower 50%	44% Math proficiency	686
7	Howard L Hall Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades K–5	Public	37.3 Lower 50%	42% Math proficiency	539
8	College Lakes Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades K–5	Public	30.8 Lower 50%	35% Math proficiency	459
9	E E Miller Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	30.1 Lower 50%	41% Math proficiency	656
10	J W Coon Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	29.3 Lower 50%	32% Math proficiency	186
11	Brentwood Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	27.9 Lower 50%	32% Math proficiency	494
12	Ashley Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades 3–5	Public	25.4 Lower 50%	27% Math proficiency	180
13	Alderman Road Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	25.3 Lower 50%	37% Math proficiency	655
14	Elizabeth M Cashwell Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	24.6 Lower 50%	34% Math proficiency	576
15	Glendale Acres Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–2	Public	23.5 Lower 50%	98.8% Free/reduced-price lunch	251
16	Cumberland Road Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	23.2 Lower 50%	27% Math proficiency	337
17	Lucile Souders Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	22.9 Lower 50%	28% Math proficiency	399
18	Cliffdale Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	22.0 Lower 50%	24% Math proficiency	613
19	Warrenwood Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	21.8 Lower 50%	27% Math proficiency	424
20	Ponderosa Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	21.4 Lower 50%	32% Math proficiency	417
21	Montclair Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	20.9 Lower 50%	22% Math proficiency	433
22	William H Owen Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	20.8 Lower 50%	22% Math proficiency	393
23	Sherwood Park Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	20.4 Lower 50%	17% Math proficiency	335
24	Benjamin J Martin Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	19.8 Lower 50%	25% Math proficiency	522
25	Cumberland Mills Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	19.7 Lower 50%	31% Math proficiency	573
26	Margaret Willis Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	19.3 Lower 50%	22% Math proficiency	296
27	Loyd E Auman Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	18.8 Lower 50%	25% Math proficiency	495
28	Bill Hefner Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	18.7 Lower 50%	24% Math proficiency	712
29	Mary McArthur Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	18.1 Lower 50%	24% Math proficiency	447
30	Lake Rim Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	17.3 Lower 50%	22% Math proficiency	656
31	Westarea Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	16.8 Lower 50%	18% Math proficiency	546
32	Walker-Spivey Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	16.3 Lower 50%	22% Math proficiency	345
33	Alma O Easom Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades K–1	Public	15.8 Lower 50%	99% Free/reduced-price lunch	301
34	Morganton Road Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades K–5	Public	15.0 Lower 50%	23% Math proficiency	491
35	Ferguson-Easley Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades PK–5	Public	13.8 Lower 50%	17% Math proficiency	392
36	Sunnyside Elementary Fayetteville · Elementary · Grades K–5	Public	13.2 Lower 50%	22% Math proficiency	362

Stoney Point Elementary in Fayetteville leads the 2025 list of elementary schools in Fayetteville with a Success Index (US) of 44.4. Of the 36 schools shown, 36 are public.

For the full picture see the wider North Carolina elementary schools rankings, every school on the Fayetteville page, or the comparison tool to put a shortlist side by side.

Free academic assessment

Is your child on grade level in reading and math?

Success Tutoring offers personalised English and math tutoring from Kindergarten to Grade 12. Start with a free online assessment and a clear plan for the year ahead.

Personalised learning plan mapped to the Australian Curriculum
English & Maths from Kindergarten to Year 12
Flexible memberships, no lock-in contracts
Centres across NSW, VIC, QLD, WA, SA and ACT

Frequently asked questions

What is the best elementary school in Fayetteville?

Stoney Point Elementary in Fayetteville, North Carolina ranks first among elementary schools in Fayetteville with a Success Index (US) of 44.4 out of 100 (Enrollment: 780).

How are elementary schools in Fayetteville ranked?

Each school's Success Index (US) combines 4 factors: math proficiency (30%), reading proficiency (30%), community advantage (fewer free/reduced-price lunch) (25%), students per teacher (15%). Each factor is a percentile against schools of the same type across United States. Schools with fewer than 60 students are excluded from rankings.

Are these 2025 rankings official?

No. They are computed by Success Tutoring from official American data (Urban Institute Education Data Portal (NCES CCD, EDFacts); NCES Common Core of Data). States set their own assessments and proficiency cut scores, so proficiency rates are most comparable within a state. Use the state rankings for like-for-like comparisons.