Best elementary schools in Toledo (2025)
Schools classified as elementary by NCES. Ranked by the Success Index (US) from official American data; 63 schools in Toledo, Ohio. Rank positions shown on each profile are within United States and Ohio.
- 184Ottawa Hills Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary92% Math proficiency · 554 students
- 279Elmhurst Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary78% Math proficiency · 381 students
- 378Whiteford Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary77% Math proficiency · 418 students
- 474Grove Patterson Academy Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary65% Math proficiency · 370 students
- 573Stranahan Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary65% Math proficiency · 502 students
- 670Toledo Preparatory and Fitness AcademyToledo · Charter Elementary72% Math proficiency · 292 students
- 766Mcgregor Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary73% Math proficiency · 377 students
- 864Dorr Street Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary65% Math proficiency · 392 students
- 964Edgewater Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary52% Math proficiency · 124 students
- 1061Winterfield Venture AcademyToledo · Charter Elementary44% Math proficiency · 376 students
- 1161Monac Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary66% Math proficiency · 465 students
- 1260Chase STEM AcademyToledo · Public Elementary66% Math proficiency · 245 students
- 1359Old West End Academy Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary42% Math proficiency · 272 students
- 1459Beverly Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary56% Math proficiency · 557 students
- 1557Hiawatha Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary67% Math proficiency · 309 students
- 1657Shoreland Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary58% Math proficiency · 650 students
- 1751Bennett Venture AcademyToledo · Charter Elementary44% Math proficiency · 460 students
- 1849Ottawa River Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary47% Math proficiency · 375 students
- 1949Greenwood Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary58% Math proficiency · 511 students
- 2048Meadowvale Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary55% Math proficiency · 510 students
- 2148Harvard Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary37% Math proficiency · 262 students
- 2247Byrnedale Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary39% Math proficiency · 316 students
- 2346Escuela SMART AcademyToledo · Public Elementary– · 287 students
- 2445Burroughs Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary36% Math proficiency · 310 students
- 2542Western Toledo Preparatory AcademyToledo · Charter Elementary– · 310 students
- 2640Horizon Science Academy-SpringfieldToledo · Charter Elementary40% Math proficiency · 331 students
- 2739Discovery AcademyToledo · Charter Elementary47% Math proficiency · 316 students
- 2838L. Hollingworth School for Talented and GiftedToledo · Charter Elementary39% Math proficiency · 303 students
- 2938Silver Creek Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary52% Math proficiency · 679 students
- 3037Larchmont Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary30% Math proficiency · 394 students
- 3134Glendale-Feilbach Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary30% Math proficiency · 335 students
- 3234Rise & Shine AcademyToledo · Charter Elementary27% Math proficiency · 94 students
- 3334Oakdale Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary36% Math proficiency · 392 students
- 3430Hawkins Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary36% Math proficiency · 355 students
- 3529Kenmore Preparatory Academy dba Toledo Preparatory AcademyToledo · Charter Elementary– · 386 students
- 3629Martin Luther King Academy for Boys Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary32% Math proficiency · 152 students
- 3728McTigue Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary32% Math proficiency · 552 students
- 3828Walbridge Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary37% Math proficiency · 264 students
- 3927Longfellow Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary39% Math proficiency · 471 students
- 4026DeVeaux Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary29% Math proficiency · 431 students
- 4126Old Orchard Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary27% Math proficiency · 414 students
- 4225Ella P. Stewart Academy for GirlsToledo · Public Elementary32% Math proficiency · 213 students
- 4325Whittier Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary35% Math proficiency · 485 students
- 4424Arlington Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary28% Math proficiency · 305 students
- 4522Navarre Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary27% Math proficiency · 345 students
- 4619Birmingham Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary16% Math proficiency · 313 students
- 4718East Broadway Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary15% Math proficiency · 416 students
- 4818Riverside Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary22% Math proficiency · 340 students
- 4917Madison Avenue School of ArtsToledo · Charter Elementary26% Math proficiency · 392 students
- 5016Ann Jerkins-Harris Academy of ExcellenceToledo · Charter Elementary17% Math proficiency · 129 students
- 5116Glenwood Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary12% Math proficiency · 281 students
- 5214McKinley STEMM AcademyToledo · Public Elementary22% Math proficiency · 323 students
- 5312Pickett Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary17% Math proficiency · 209 students
- 5412Garfield Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary20% Math proficiency · 435 students
- 5512Keyser Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary12% Math proficiency · 306 students
- 5612Spring Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary27% Math proficiency · 239 students
- 5711Raymer Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary15% Math proficiency · 381 students
- 5810Sherman Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary12% Math proficiency · 339 students
- 599Marshall STEMM AcademyToledo · Public Elementary14% Math proficiency · 366 students
- 606SunBridge SchoolsToledo · Charter Elementary12% Math proficiency · 267 students
- 615Robinson Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary12% Math proficiency · 415 students
- 624Rosa Parks Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary7.5% Math proficiency · 284 students
- 633Leverette Elementary SchoolToledo · Public Elementary13% Math proficiency · 472 students
| # | School | Sector | Success Index (US) | Key result | Students |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ottawa Hills Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–6 | Public | 83.8 Top 10% | 92% Math proficiency | 554 |
| 2 | Elmhurst Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Public | 78.5 Top 25% | 78% Math proficiency | 381 |
| 3 | Whiteford Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–5 | Public | 77.8 Top 25% | 77% Math proficiency | 418 |
| 4 | Grove Patterson Academy Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 73.8 Top 25% | 65% Math proficiency | 370 |
| 5 | Stranahan Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–5 | Public | 73.0 Top 25% | 65% Math proficiency | 502 |
| 6 | Toledo Preparatory and Fitness Academy Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Charter | 70.3 Top 25% | 72% Math proficiency | 292 |
| 7 | Mcgregor Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–6 | Public | 65.5 Top 50% | 73% Math proficiency | 377 |
| 8 | Dorr Street Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–3 | Public | 64.4 Top 50% | 65% Math proficiency | 392 |
| 9 | Edgewater Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–5 | Public | 64.3 Top 50% | 52% Math proficiency | 124 |
| 10 | Winterfield Venture Academy Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Charter | 61.0 Top 50% | 44% Math proficiency | 376 |
| 11 | Monac Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–6 | Public | 60.7 Top 50% | 66% Math proficiency | 465 |
| 12 | Chase STEM Academy Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Public | 59.6 Top 50% | 66% Math proficiency | 245 |
| 13 | Old West End Academy Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Public | 59.0 Top 50% | 42% Math proficiency | 272 |
| 14 | Beverly Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 58.6 Top 50% | 56% Math proficiency | 557 |
| 15 | Hiawatha Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–6 | Public | 57.3 Top 50% | 67% Math proficiency | 309 |
| 16 | Shoreland Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–6 | Public | 57.2 Top 50% | 58% Math proficiency | 650 |
| 17 | Bennett Venture Academy Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Charter | 50.6 Top 50% | 44% Math proficiency | 460 |
| 18 | Ottawa River Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 48.7 Lower 50% | 47% Math proficiency | 375 |
| 19 | Greenwood Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–6 | Public | 48.5 Lower 50% | 58% Math proficiency | 511 |
| 20 | Meadowvale Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–6 | Public | 47.9 Lower 50% | 55% Math proficiency | 510 |
| 21 | Harvard Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 47.6 Lower 50% | 37% Math proficiency | 262 |
| 22 | Byrnedale Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 46.7 Lower 50% | 39% Math proficiency | 316 |
| 23 | Escuela SMART Academy Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–6 | Public | 46.4 Lower 50% | – | 287 |
| 24 | Burroughs Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Public | 45.2 Lower 50% | 36% Math proficiency | 310 |
| 25 | Western Toledo Preparatory Academy Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Charter | 41.6 Lower 50% | – | 310 |
| 26 | Horizon Science Academy-Springfield Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Charter | 39.7 Lower 50% | 40% Math proficiency | 331 |
| 27 | Discovery Academy Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–6 | Charter | 38.7 Lower 50% | 47% Math proficiency | 316 |
| 28 | L. Hollingworth School for Talented and Gifted Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Charter | 37.7 Lower 50% | 39% Math proficiency | 303 |
| 29 | Silver Creek Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–6 | Public | 37.7 Lower 50% | 52% Math proficiency | 679 |
| 30 | Larchmont Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Public | 36.6 Lower 50% | 30% Math proficiency | 394 |
| 31 | Glendale-Feilbach Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Public | 33.7 Lower 50% | 30% Math proficiency | 335 |
| 32 | Rise & Shine Academy Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–6 | Charter | 33.7 Lower 50% | 27% Math proficiency | 94 |
| 33 | Oakdale Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 33.6 Lower 50% | 36% Math proficiency | 392 |
| 34 | Hawkins Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Public | 29.6 Lower 50% | 36% Math proficiency | 355 |
| 35 | Kenmore Preparatory Academy dba Toledo Preparatory Academy Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Charter | 29.4 Lower 50% | – | 386 |
| 36 | Martin Luther King Academy for Boys Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–6 | Public | 29.0 Lower 50% | 32% Math proficiency | 152 |
| 37 | McTigue Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 28.4 Lower 50% | 32% Math proficiency | 552 |
| 38 | Walbridge Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Public | 27.7 Lower 50% | 37% Math proficiency | 264 |
| 39 | Longfellow Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Public | 26.7 Lower 50% | 39% Math proficiency | 471 |
| 40 | DeVeaux Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Public | 26.1 Lower 50% | 29% Math proficiency | 431 |
| 41 | Old Orchard Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 25.9 Lower 50% | 27% Math proficiency | 414 |
| 42 | Ella P. Stewart Academy for Girls Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–6 | Public | 25.3 Lower 50% | 32% Math proficiency | 213 |
| 43 | Whittier Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Public | 25.3 Lower 50% | 35% Math proficiency | 485 |
| 44 | Arlington Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Public | 23.7 Lower 50% | 28% Math proficiency | 305 |
| 45 | Navarre Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 21.7 Lower 50% | 27% Math proficiency | 345 |
| 46 | Birmingham Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 18.6 Lower 50% | 16% Math proficiency | 313 |
| 47 | East Broadway Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 17.9 Lower 50% | 15% Math proficiency | 416 |
| 48 | Riverside Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 17.9 Lower 50% | 22% Math proficiency | 340 |
| 49 | Madison Avenue School of Arts Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–6 | Charter | 16.6 Lower 50% | 26% Math proficiency | 392 |
| 50 | Ann Jerkins-Harris Academy of Excellence Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Charter | 16.2 Lower 50% | 17% Math proficiency | 129 |
| 51 | Glenwood Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 15.9 Lower 50% | 12% Math proficiency | 281 |
| 52 | McKinley STEMM Academy Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Public | 14.1 Lower 50% | 22% Math proficiency | 323 |
| 53 | Pickett Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–8 | Public | 12.3 Lower 50% | 17% Math proficiency | 209 |
| 54 | Garfield Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 11.6 Lower 50% | 20% Math proficiency | 435 |
| 55 | Keyser Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 11.5 Lower 50% | 12% Math proficiency | 306 |
| 56 | Spring Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 11.5 Lower 50% | 27% Math proficiency | 239 |
| 57 | Raymer Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 10.5 Lower 50% | 15% Math proficiency | 381 |
| 58 | Sherman Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 10.1 Lower 50% | 12% Math proficiency | 339 |
| 59 | Marshall STEMM Academy Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 9.0 Lower 50% | 14% Math proficiency | 366 |
| 60 | SunBridge Schools Toledo · Elementary · Grades K–6 | Charter | 5.8 Lower 50% | 12% Math proficiency | 267 |
| 61 | Robinson Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 4.7 Lower 50% | 12% Math proficiency | 415 |
| 62 | Rosa Parks Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 3.7 Lower 50% | 7.5% Math proficiency | 284 |
| 63 | Leverette Elementary School Toledo · Elementary · Grades PK–8 | Public | 3.2 Lower 50% | 13% Math proficiency | 472 |
Ottawa Hills Elementary School in Toledo leads the 2025 list of elementary schools in Toledo with a Success Index (US) of 83.8. Of the 63 schools shown, 51 are public, 12 are charter.
For the full picture see the wider Ohio elementary schools rankings, every school on the Toledo page, or the comparison tool to put a shortlist side by side.
Free academic assessment
Is your child on grade level in reading and math?
Success Tutoring offers personalised English and math tutoring from Kindergarten to Grade 12. Start with a free online assessment and a clear plan for the year ahead.
- Personalised learning plan mapped to the Australian Curriculum
- English & Maths from Kindergarten to Year 12
- Flexible memberships, no lock-in contracts
- Centres across NSW, VIC, QLD, WA, SA and ACT
Frequently asked questions
What is the best elementary school in Toledo?
Ottawa Hills Elementary School in Toledo, Ohio ranks first among elementary schools in Toledo with a Success Index (US) of 83.8 out of 100 (Enrollment: 554).
How are elementary schools in Toledo ranked?
Each school's Success Index (US) combines 4 factors: math proficiency (30%), reading proficiency (30%), community advantage (fewer free/reduced-price lunch) (25%), students per teacher (15%). Each factor is a percentile against schools of the same type across United States. Schools with fewer than 60 students are excluded from rankings.
Are these 2025 rankings official?
No. They are computed by Success Tutoring from official American data (Urban Institute Education Data Portal (NCES CCD, EDFacts); NCES Common Core of Data). States set their own assessments and proficiency cut scores, so proficiency rates are most comparable within a state. Use the state rankings for like-for-like comparisons.