Schools in Bay Shore, New York (2025)
13 schools · 8,732 students · 13 public · median Enrollment 609.
Bay Shore, in New York, has 13 schools in United States's 2025 data, together educating about 8,732 students. By level there are 10 elementary, 2 middle, 1 high; by sector 13 public.
The median Enrollment across Bay Shore's schools is 609, above the New York median of 428. Students enrolled in the latest NCES directory year.
11 of the 13 schools qualify for the Success Index (US). The highest-scoring is Bay Shore Senior High School (84.7, top 5% of high schools nationally), followed by Fifth Avenue School (83.7, top 10% of elementary schools nationally), and Brook Avenue Elementary School (80.4, top 10% of elementary schools nationally). 3 schools sit in the top 10% of United States for their type. Scores are percentiles within school type, so compare an elementary school with other elementary schools.
The largest schools are Bay Shore Senior High School (1,862 students), Bay Shore Middle School (1,258 students), Southwest Elementary School (975 students).
Ranked schools in Bay Shore
Ordered by Success Index (US). Rank positions shown on each profile are within United States and New York.
- 185Bay Shore Senior High SchoolBay Shore · Public High89% Math proficiency · 1,862 students
- 284Fifth Avenue SchoolBay Shore · Public Elementary36.3% Free/reduced-price lunch · 342 students
- 380Brook Avenue Elementary SchoolBay Shore · Public Elementary42.3% Free/reduced-price lunch · 336 students
- 475Mary G Clarkson SchoolBay Shore · Public Elementary47.8% Free/reduced-price lunch · 469 students
- 558Bay Shore Middle SchoolBay Shore · Public Middle46% Math proficiency · 1,258 students
- 657South Country SchoolBay Shore · Public Elementary37% Math proficiency · 496 students
- 744Gardiner Manor SchoolBay Shore · Public Elementary31% Math proficiency · 739 students
- 832West Middle SchoolBay Shore · Public Middle37% Math proficiency · 906 students
- 926Southwest Elementary SchoolBay Shore · Public Elementary29% Math proficiency · 975 students
- 1026Oak Park Elementary SchoolBay Shore · Public Elementary32% Math proficiency · 678 students
- 1124Hemlock Elementary SchoolBay Shore · Public Elementary27% Math proficiency · 609 students
| # | School | Sector | Success Index (US) | Key result | Students |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bay Shore Senior High School Bay Shore · High · Grades 9–12 | Public | 84.7 Top 5% | 89% Math proficiency | 1,862 |
| 2 | Fifth Avenue School Bay Shore · Elementary · Grades K–2 | Public | 83.7 Top 10% | 36.3% Free/reduced-price lunch | 342 |
| 3 | Brook Avenue Elementary School Bay Shore · Elementary · Grades K–2 | Public | 80.4 Top 10% | 42.3% Free/reduced-price lunch | 336 |
| 4 | Mary G Clarkson School Bay Shore · Elementary · Grades K–2 | Public | 74.9 Top 25% | 47.8% Free/reduced-price lunch | 469 |
| 5 | Bay Shore Middle School Bay Shore · Middle · Grades 6–8 | Public | 57.9 Top 50% | 46% Math proficiency | 1,258 |
| 6 | South Country School Bay Shore · Elementary · Grades 3–5 | Public | 56.7 Top 50% | 37% Math proficiency | 496 |
| 7 | Gardiner Manor School Bay Shore · Elementary · Grades 3–5 | Public | 43.7 Lower 50% | 31% Math proficiency | 739 |
| 8 | West Middle School Bay Shore · Middle · Grades 6–8 | Public | 31.9 Lower 50% | 37% Math proficiency | 906 |
| 9 | Southwest Elementary School Bay Shore · Elementary · Grades K–5 | Public | 25.7 Lower 50% | 29% Math proficiency | 975 |
| 10 | Oak Park Elementary School Bay Shore · Elementary · Grades K–5 | Public | 25.6 Lower 50% | 32% Math proficiency | 678 |
| 11 | Hemlock Elementary School Bay Shore · Elementary · Grades K–5 | Public | 24.0 Lower 50% | 27% Math proficiency | 609 |
Other schools in Bay Shore
Schools without a rank: fewer than 60 students, no published Enrollment, or a school type that is not scored.
Compare the top 4 schools in Bay Shore side by side →
Other places in New York
- Brooklyn(545)
- Bronx(442)
- New York(320)
- Rochester(103)
- Staten Island(81)
- Buffalo(80)
- Jamaica(47)
- Syracuse(43)
- Flushing(42)
- Yonkers(40)
- Long Island City(36)
- Schenectady(32)
- Albany(32)
- Poughkeepsie(20)
- Binghamton(18)
- Troy(17)
- Elmhurst(16)
- Bayside(16)
- Far Rockaway(16)
- Mount Vernon(16)
- Springfield Gardens(15)
- Corona(14)
- Valley Stream(14)
- Utica(14)
- Niagara Falls(13)
- Brentwood(13)
- Cheektowaga(13)
- Liverpool(13)
- South Ozone Park(12)
- Ithaca(12)
- Scarsdale(12)
- Levittown(12)
- Jamestown(12)
- Hempstead(11)
- Elmira(11)
- Hamburg(11)
- Williamsville(11)
- Lockport(11)
- Clifton Park(11)
- Webster(11)
Free academic assessment
Is your child on grade level in reading and math?
Success Tutoring offers personalised English and math tutoring from Kindergarten to Grade 12. Start with a free online assessment and a clear plan for the year ahead.
- Personalised learning plan mapped to the Australian Curriculum
- English & Maths from Kindergarten to Year 12
- Flexible memberships, no lock-in contracts
- Centres across NSW, VIC, QLD, WA, SA and ACT
Frequently asked questions
What is the best school in Bay Shore?
Bay Shore Senior High School is the highest-ranked school in Bay Shore with a Success Index (US) of 84.7 out of 100 (Top 5% of high schools in United States).
How many schools are in Bay Shore?
Bay Shore has 13 schools (1 high, 10 elementary, 2 middle) educating 8,732 students in 2025.
What is the typical Enrollment in Bay Shore?
The median Enrollment across schools in Bay Shore is 609. Students enrolled in the latest NCES directory year.